Soluble vs. Insoluble Fiber: What's the Difference?

You may have heard that fiber is good for us and that we generally need more of it, but do you really know what it is?

Fiber is a carbohydrate but with an interesting twist. Unlike other carbohydrates such as sugars or starches, fiber does not get digested and absorbed in the traditional sense. Fibers are long chains of carbohydrates that withstand our body’s digestive process. In other words, they do not get broken up by our digestive enzymes nor do they provide us with any calories, or energy. It is their indigestible nature which provides us with unique health benefits.

What’s more, is that there are two distinct types of fiber, soluble and insoluble which differ in their physical structure and impact on health. When soluble fiber, found in oats, chia seeds, psyllium husks, legumes and some fruits, is combined with water it forms a gel-like substance. In the digestive tract, this viscous gel-like substance helps combat diarrhea and has been shown to improve blood sugar control by slowing down the release of glucose into the bloodstream. Along with its effect on blood sugars, soluble fiber also disrupts the absorption of dietary cholesterol and can improve LDL (or “bad”) cholesterol. 

There is also evidence that suggests that soluble fiber plays a role in satiating hunger (or keeping us fuller for longer). This may explain why a bowl of oatmeal is so filling or “sticks to your ribs”, as they say. Some types of soluble fibers are also broken down and fermented by the beneficial bacteria in our large intestine as a food source, or prebiotic.

sol v insol2.JPG

Unlike soluble fiber, the insoluble fiber found in many fruits, vegetables and whole grains does not form a gel in the digestive tract. Rather, it serves to provide bulk and structure to our stool which benefits our large intestine. Diets high in insoluble fiber are associated with less constipation, and helpful in the management of diverticular disease and hemorrhoids.

Current dietary recommendations for fiber are 25 grams per day for adult women and 38 grams per day for adult men. Most people eat well under this amount of fiber. While both types of fiber are needed, it’s not generally necessary to keep a daily tally of the amounts of each type of fiber you are eating. You’d probably drive yourself mad doing this. The good thing is that most sources of fiber do contain a bit of both types but differ in the proportions of each they contain. Some foods contain a higher percentage of soluble fiber while others contain more insoluble fiber. If you need better blood sugar or cholesterol control, you may benefit from choosing foods with a higher percentage of soluble fiber (like oats or pears), while those with constipation may want to include those with more insoluble fiber (like wheat bran).

For the most part, what's really important is to focus on total fiber intake and ensure that it meets the recommended amount (25 g for women and 38 g for men). This can be done by including lots of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, nuts and seeds in your diet each day. When reading the nutrition facts label, look for foods with at least 2 grams of fiber per serving. Those with 4 or more grams of fiber are considered ‘high fiber’ and definitely worth including. If you want a complete list of fiber containing foods, check here.

An important note:  remember to increase fiber intake slowly and to make sure you are drinking enough fluids. Fibers need fluids, or else you’ll find yourself constipated (or more constipated). While there isn’t a specific recommendation for the amount of fluids to be drinking per increment of dietary fiber, you can start with 6-8 cups of fluids per day (water, tea, coffee, soup, etc) and take more if needed (if exercising or in hot, humid weather).

 Foods with 4 or more grams of fiber per serving are considered high fiber. Choose these foods when possible. These granola bars contain 5 grams of fiber per serving (per bar). 

Foods with 4 or more grams of fiber per serving are considered high fiber. Choose these foods when possible. These granola bars contain 5 grams of fiber per serving (per bar). 

 This food (rice crackers) contain no fiber. 

This food (rice crackers) contain no fiber. 

TBwhite w200.jpg